Most Overrated Band Member of All TIme

[Marky Dread]

Morrissey easily the worst drummer in The Smiths.

That's nothing, you should hear him play piano

With a sponge and rusty spanner.

[Wolter]

I left Cluj-Napoca in September of last year, so I don't know which "original member" was performing.

Probably the one who didn’t kill himself.

EDIT: By accidental overdose, not suicide.

[Kory]

Just sounds like being in that band I was in. But really there's only a couple bass players that are rated at all, much less overrated.

When I read Pete Jones' memoir, he clearly thinks Jah Wobble is overrated.

Flowers of Romance begs to differ.

As is his absence is missed?

Ah shit I meant it's possible proof. Sorry, I'm doing like a million things at once right now.

[Dr. Medulla]

Just sounds like being in that band I was in. But really there's only a couple bass players that are rated at all, much less overrated.

When I read Pete Jones' memoir, he clearly thinks Jah Wobble is overrated.

Flowers of Romance begs to differ.

As is his absence is missed?

Ah shit I meant it's possible proof. Sorry, I'm doing like a million things at once right now.

And you failed at this one! Atone!

[JennyB]

I think a lot of these comments are veering more into unnecessary band members, rather than overrated. I know you will all be shocked that I am using DM as an example, but Andrew Fletcher is unnecessary to Depeche Mode. Vince Clark is overrated.

[laxman]

I asked Keith Levene and he said "Mick Jones".

[Olaf]

I asked Keith Levene and he said "Mick Jones".

[Olaf]

Richey Edwards

[Kory]

When I read Pete Jones' memoir, he clearly thinks Jah Wobble is overrated.

Flowers of Romance begs to differ.

As is his absence is missed?

Ah shit I meant it's possible proof. Sorry, I'm doing like a million things at once right now.

And you failed at this one! Atone!

Just go easy on the Wreck of the Hesperus.

[101Walterton]

Andrew Ridgley.

[BitterTom]

As much as I like Green Day, Billie Joe Armstrong.

[Dr. Medulla]

Flowers of Romance begs to differ.

As is his absence is missed?

Ah shit I meant it's possible proof. Sorry, I'm doing like a million things at once right now.

And you failed at this one! Atone!

Just go easy on the Wreck of the Hesperus.

Extra "Wreck of the Hesperus"!

[Dr. Medulla]

Andrew Ridgley.

Save that one for the Most Forgettable Band Member thread.

[101Walterton]

Andrew Ridgley.

Save that one for the Most Forgettable Band Member thread.

I might forget

[Dr. Medulla]

Andrew Ridgley.

Save that one for the Most Forgettable Band Member thread.

I might forget

And that thread collapses before being born.