With the Beatles / Side A / Round 3

[WestwayKid]

"Little Child" has been eliminated.

[WestwayKid]

Going with Please Mr. Postman in this round. It pales not only in comparison to the original, but I think it's the weakest track remaining.

[Wolter]

Going with Please Mr. Postman in this round. It pales not only in comparison to the original, but I think it's the weakest track remaining.

Same.

[Heston]

I'm not sure if I've heard the original of Postman but I really like the Beatles version, especially the backing vocals. Gonna have a listen now.

[BitterTom]

Don't Bother Me, sounds half arsed and prime filler.

[Dr. Medulla]

Going with Please Mr. Postman in this round. It pales not only in comparison to the original, but I think it's the weakest track remaining.

That's an example where I'll certainly say the original is vastly superior.

[Heston]

Going with Please Mr. Postman in this round. It pales not only in comparison to the original, but I think it's the weakest track remaining.

That's an example where I'll certainly say the original is vastly superior.

Yeah, just listened. Great vocal. It never charted in the UK and I've never heard it on the radio so always just knew the Beatles and Carpenters versions.

[gkbill]

Going with Please Mr. Postman in this round. It pales not only in comparison to the original, but I think it's the weakest track remaining.

That's an example where I'll certainly say the original is vastly superior.

Yeah, just listened. Great vocal. It never charted in the UK and I've never heard it on the radio so always just knew the Beatles and Carpenters versions.

Hello,

The Beatles cover isn't bad but the Marvelettes' version and vocals just stick in my mind so much more.

[Inder]

Here it is with Pete Best:

[Inder]

And here's a great cover of Don't Bother Me:



Really reveals it to be a fun samba-twist thing, which was so in vogue around '63.

[Wolter]

Going with Please Mr. Postman in this round. It pales not only in comparison to the original, but I think it's the weakest track remaining.

That's an example where I'll certainly say the original is vastly superior.

I know I’m an extremist on this front already, but the original in this case is inarguably superior.

[tepista]

Going with Please Mr. Postman in this round. It pales not only in comparison to the original, but I think it's the weakest track remaining.

this one, I agree. Marvelettes version is an alltime fave