Revolver - Side A - Round 2

[WestwayKid]

George Harrison has not been doing well in this poll so far.

“I thought until this album that George’s songs weren’t that good."

Paul McCartney, September 8th, 1969.

[Silent Majority]

George Harrison has not been doing well in this poll so far.

“I thought until this album that George’s songs weren’t that good."

Paul McCartney, September 8th, 1969.

I'm going to continue the trend by voting for Taxman. Pay your way, you millionaire jerk.

[Heston]

I'm gonna keep voting for Here, There and Everywhere because it is hideously cloying.

[Wolter]

I like every single song on this album it turns out. Even the ones other people hate.

[Heston]

George Harrison has not been doing well in this poll so far.

“I thought until this album that George’s songs weren’t that good."

Paul McCartney, September 8th, 1969.

I'm going to continue the trend by voting for Taxman. Pay your way, you millionaire jerk.

But that bass line. And that guitar solo.

[Silent Majority]

George Harrison has not been doing well in this poll so far.

“I thought until this album that George’s songs weren’t that good."

Paul McCartney, September 8th, 1969.

I'm going to continue the trend by voting for Taxman. Pay your way, you millionaire jerk.

But that bass line. And that guitar solo.

If I want that bassline and guitar sound, I'll just listen to Start!

[Dr. Medulla]

George Harrison has not been doing well in this poll so far.

“I thought until this album that George’s songs weren’t that good."

Paul McCartney, September 8th, 1969.

I'm going to continue the trend by voting for Taxman. Pay your way, you millionaire jerk.

I'm with you here, tho I'm first targeting the mopey "Eleanor Rigby."

[Silent Majority]

George Harrison has not been doing well in this poll so far.

“I thought until this album that George’s songs weren’t that good."

Paul McCartney, September 8th, 1969.

I'm going to continue the trend by voting for Taxman. Pay your way, you millionaire jerk.

I'm with you here, tho I'm first targeting the mopey "Eleanor Rigby."

I like 'Rigby.' But Martin should have learnt the lesson from Yesterday and just let the song be without over-orchestrating. Let them play bass, guitar and drums, it's the idiom that fits 'em best.

[Dr. Medulla]

George Harrison has not been doing well in this poll so far.

“I thought until this album that George’s songs weren’t that good."

Paul McCartney, September 8th, 1969.

I'm going to continue the trend by voting for Taxman. Pay your way, you millionaire jerk.

I'm with you here, tho I'm first targeting the mopey "Eleanor Rigby."

I like 'Rigby.' But Martin should have learnt the lesson from Yesterday and just let the song be without over-orchestrating. Let them play bass, guitar and drums, it's the idiom that fits 'em best.

I may well be more sympathetic if not for the retrograde effort at "respectability" with those strings. It works against the forward-thinking of the record as a whole. Let's blow the minds of the kids, but here's something for grandpa and grandma.

[Dr. Medulla]

And three votes off the bat for "She Said"? Wow. I saw that as a song that wouldn't get a single negative vote until the latter rounds when nuts get cut.

[Silent Majority]

And three votes off the bat for "She Said"? Wow. I saw that as a song that wouldn't get a single negative vote until the latter rounds when nuts get cut.

Great track.

[Heston]

ER is perfect. Best song on the album.

[Dr. Medulla]

ER is perfect. Best song on the album.

Jaw status: Dropped.

[WestwayKid]

I really like She Said She Said. It is a fantastic track. Great playing throughout (Ringo never sounded better). George's lead riff is great. Lennon's vocal delivery is spot on, druggy, yet tough. Paul's bass is buried a bit too far in the mix, but listen closely - it's really, really good.

There is just no world in which this track deserves to be eliminated this early. It's not as good as I'm Only Sleeping, but better than everything else on this side.

[Heston]

ER is perfect. Best song on the album.

Jaw status: Dropped.

Is it that outlandish a claim? I just did a cursory search of Beatles songs ranked and it was at number 12. And that's their whole output.