Star Trek
- BostonBeaneater
- Autonomous Insect Cyborg Sentinel
- Posts: 11953
- Joined: 15 Jun 2008, 7:24pm
- Location: Between the moon and New York City
Re: Star Trek
I hope Q continues to harass him during his retirement.
- Dr. Medulla
- Atheistic Epileptic
- Posts: 116571
- Joined: 15 Jun 2008, 2:00pm
- Location: Straight Banana, Idaho
Re: Star Trek
"I, Borg" is on right now. Christ but Picard and Riker are quick to endorse genocide. As in bloodless logic, no regrets (rather Borglike in that respect). Crusher is the only one with a conscience. Even Picard's change of heart comes from Hugh expressing an individualist perspective, so wiping out collective societies is seemingly still on the table. By all rights, Picard's and Riker's standing with at least some fans should be seriously compromised.
"Grab some wood, bub.'" - Richard Nixon, Checkers Speech, abandoned early draft
Re: Star Trek
Aren't the Borg kind of like a humanoid space virus though?Dr. Medulla wrote: ↑07 Aug 2018, 3:22pm"I, Borg" is on right now. Christ but Picard and Riker are quick to endorse genocide. As in bloodless logic, no regrets (rather Borglike in that respect). Crusher is the only one with a conscience. Even Picard's change of heart comes from Hugh expressing an individualist perspective, so wiping out collective societies is seemingly still on the table. By all rights, Picard's and Riker's standing with at least some fans should be seriously compromised.
"Suck our Earth dick, Martians!" —Doc
- BostonBeaneater
- Autonomous Insect Cyborg Sentinel
- Posts: 11953
- Joined: 15 Jun 2008, 7:24pm
- Location: Between the moon and New York City
Re: Star Trek
They earned it just like the Japanese.Dr. Medulla wrote: ↑07 Aug 2018, 3:22pm"I, Borg" is on right now. Christ but Picard and Riker are quick to endorse genocide. As in bloodless logic, no regrets (rather Borglike in that respect). Crusher is the only one with a conscience. Even Picard's change of heart comes from Hugh expressing an individualist perspective, so wiping out collective societies is seemingly still on the table. By all rights, Picard's and Riker's standing with at least some fans should be seriously compromised.
- Dr. Medulla
- Atheistic Epileptic
- Posts: 116571
- Joined: 15 Jun 2008, 2:00pm
- Location: Straight Banana, Idaho
Re: Star Trek
It's that kind of rationalization, tho, that facillitates a genocidal solution. Denying any connection, any shared quality between you and your enemy makes it easier to assert a different set of rules between you and them, including those that cover the morality of genocide. Given that Starfleet is supposed to represent the greatest of humanity's values and this search to meet other peoples, Picard and Riker way too quickly and remorselessly go to genocide. It's that almost eagerness that is so offputting.Kory wrote: ↑08 Aug 2018, 3:10pmAren't the Borg kind of like a humanoid space virus though?Dr. Medulla wrote: ↑07 Aug 2018, 3:22pm"I, Borg" is on right now. Christ but Picard and Riker are quick to endorse genocide. As in bloodless logic, no regrets (rather Borglike in that respect). Crusher is the only one with a conscience. Even Picard's change of heart comes from Hugh expressing an individualist perspective, so wiping out collective societies is seemingly still on the table. By all rights, Picard's and Riker's standing with at least some fans should be seriously compromised.
Last edited by Dr. Medulla on 08 Aug 2018, 4:10pm, edited 1 time in total.
"Grab some wood, bub.'" - Richard Nixon, Checkers Speech, abandoned early draft
- BostonBeaneater
- Autonomous Insect Cyborg Sentinel
- Posts: 11953
- Joined: 15 Jun 2008, 7:24pm
- Location: Between the moon and New York City
Re: Star Trek
I have to disagree. Threats like the Borg or like Trump need a swift clock in the jaw and a swift neutering.Dr. Medulla wrote: ↑08 Aug 2018, 3:45pmIt's that kind of rationalization, tho, that facillitates a genocidal solution. Denying any connection, any shared quality between you and your enemy makes it easier to assert a different set of rules between you and them, including those that say genocide is wrong. Given that Starfleet is supposed to represent the greatest of humanity's values and this search to meet other peoples, Picard and Riker way too quickly and remorselessly go to genocide. It's that almost eagerness that is so offputting.Kory wrote: ↑08 Aug 2018, 3:10pmAren't the Borg kind of like a humanoid space virus though?Dr. Medulla wrote: ↑07 Aug 2018, 3:22pm"I, Borg" is on right now. Christ but Picard and Riker are quick to endorse genocide. As in bloodless logic, no regrets (rather Borglike in that respect). Crusher is the only one with a conscience. Even Picard's change of heart comes from Hugh expressing an individualist perspective, so wiping out collective societies is seemingly still on the table. By all rights, Picard's and Riker's standing with at least some fans should be seriously compromised.
- Dr. Medulla
- Atheistic Epileptic
- Posts: 116571
- Joined: 15 Jun 2008, 2:00pm
- Location: Straight Banana, Idaho
Re: Star Trek
Maybe. A genuine existential threat would justify that extreme action, but the Borg at that point weren't that threat. And, again, Picard goes straight to genocide—no reflection, no soul searching.BostonBeaneater wrote: ↑08 Aug 2018, 4:10pmI have to disagree. Threats like the Borg or like Trump need a swift clock in the jaw and a swift neutering.Dr. Medulla wrote: ↑08 Aug 2018, 3:45pmIt's that kind of rationalization, tho, that facillitates a genocidal solution. Denying any connection, any shared quality between you and your enemy makes it easier to assert a different set of rules between you and them, including those that say genocide is wrong. Given that Starfleet is supposed to represent the greatest of humanity's values and this search to meet other peoples, Picard and Riker way too quickly and remorselessly go to genocide. It's that almost eagerness that is so offputting.Kory wrote: ↑08 Aug 2018, 3:10pmAren't the Borg kind of like a humanoid space virus though?Dr. Medulla wrote: ↑07 Aug 2018, 3:22pm"I, Borg" is on right now. Christ but Picard and Riker are quick to endorse genocide. As in bloodless logic, no regrets (rather Borglike in that respect). Crusher is the only one with a conscience. Even Picard's change of heart comes from Hugh expressing an individualist perspective, so wiping out collective societies is seemingly still on the table. By all rights, Picard's and Riker's standing with at least some fans should be seriously compromised.
"Grab some wood, bub.'" - Richard Nixon, Checkers Speech, abandoned early draft
- BostonBeaneater
- Autonomous Insect Cyborg Sentinel
- Posts: 11953
- Joined: 15 Jun 2008, 7:24pm
- Location: Between the moon and New York City
Re: Star Trek
Didn't Guinan warn him what they were all about? It wasn't like he opted to kill them during a mixer at 10 Forward.Dr. Medulla wrote: ↑08 Aug 2018, 4:13pmMaybe. A genuine existential threat would justify that extreme action, but the Borg at that point weren't that threat. And, again, Picard goes straight to genocide—no reflection, no soul searching.BostonBeaneater wrote: ↑08 Aug 2018, 4:10pmI have to disagree. Threats like the Borg or like Trump need a swift clock in the jaw and a swift neutering.Dr. Medulla wrote: ↑08 Aug 2018, 3:45pmIt's that kind of rationalization, tho, that facillitates a genocidal solution. Denying any connection, any shared quality between you and your enemy makes it easier to assert a different set of rules between you and them, including those that say genocide is wrong. Given that Starfleet is supposed to represent the greatest of humanity's values and this search to meet other peoples, Picard and Riker way too quickly and remorselessly go to genocide. It's that almost eagerness that is so offputting.Kory wrote: ↑08 Aug 2018, 3:10pmAren't the Borg kind of like a humanoid space virus though?Dr. Medulla wrote: ↑07 Aug 2018, 3:22pm"I, Borg" is on right now. Christ but Picard and Riker are quick to endorse genocide. As in bloodless logic, no regrets (rather Borglike in that respect). Crusher is the only one with a conscience. Even Picard's change of heart comes from Hugh expressing an individualist perspective, so wiping out collective societies is seemingly still on the table. By all rights, Picard's and Riker's standing with at least some fans should be seriously compromised.
- Dr. Medulla
- Atheistic Epileptic
- Posts: 116571
- Joined: 15 Jun 2008, 2:00pm
- Location: Straight Banana, Idaho
Re: Star Trek
As I recall, he came up with the idea fairly early into the episode, but fencing with Guinan confirmed the wisdom of his plan after Crusher introduced some doubt. But where Guinan is motivate by revenge, Picard comes off as more bloodless in his rationale. At one point, he angrily tells Geordi that the Borg is a thing, not a person.BostonBeaneater wrote: ↑08 Aug 2018, 4:27pmDidn't Guinan warn him what they were all about? It wasn't like he opted to kill them during a mixer at 10 Forward.Dr. Medulla wrote: ↑08 Aug 2018, 4:13pmMaybe. A genuine existential threat would justify that extreme action, but the Borg at that point weren't that threat. And, again, Picard goes straight to genocide—no reflection, no soul searching.BostonBeaneater wrote: ↑08 Aug 2018, 4:10pmI have to disagree. Threats like the Borg or like Trump need a swift clock in the jaw and a swift neutering.Dr. Medulla wrote: ↑08 Aug 2018, 3:45pmIt's that kind of rationalization, tho, that facillitates a genocidal solution. Denying any connection, any shared quality between you and your enemy makes it easier to assert a different set of rules between you and them, including those that say genocide is wrong. Given that Starfleet is supposed to represent the greatest of humanity's values and this search to meet other peoples, Picard and Riker way too quickly and remorselessly go to genocide. It's that almost eagerness that is so offputting.
"Grab some wood, bub.'" - Richard Nixon, Checkers Speech, abandoned early draft
- Flex
- Mechano-Man of the Future
- Posts: 35943
- Joined: 15 Jun 2008, 2:50pm
- Location: The Information Superhighway!
Re: Star Trek
some TNG colony dork: Hey, we really need some power converters to run our agricultural colony, but these seemingly hostile but perhaps simply misunderstood energy space beasts are in the way of them.
Riker: Whelp, gotta wipe 'em all out. It's the only way.
STNGCD: Uhhhh, what? No, we don't need them wiped out. Just like... fly around them and pick up the converters.
Picard: What? No, we mean we have to wipe out the colony. And the space beasts. We're wiping you all out. Because we're enlightened.
Riker: Whelp, gotta wipe 'em all out. It's the only way.
STNGCD: Uhhhh, what? No, we don't need them wiped out. Just like... fly around them and pick up the converters.
Picard: What? No, we mean we have to wipe out the colony. And the space beasts. We're wiping you all out. Because we're enlightened.
Wiggle, wiggle, wiggle like a bowl of soup
Wiggle, wiggle, wiggle like a rolling hoop
Wiggle, wiggle, wiggle like a ton of lead
Wiggle - you can raise the dead
Pex Lives!
Wiggle, wiggle, wiggle like a rolling hoop
Wiggle, wiggle, wiggle like a ton of lead
Wiggle - you can raise the dead
Pex Lives!
- Flex
- Mechano-Man of the Future
- Posts: 35943
- Joined: 15 Jun 2008, 2:50pm
- Location: The Information Superhighway!
Re: Star Trek
I think you're right to critique Picard and Riker this way overall, but Picard is also dealing with it from a place of trauma - I recall the episode makes pretty clear how colored he is in his perceptions from his experience as Locutus.Dr. Medulla wrote: ↑08 Aug 2018, 4:41pmAs I recall, he came up with the idea fairly early into the episode, but fencing with Guinan confirmed the wisdom of his plan after Crusher introduced some doubt. But where Guinan is motivate by revenge, Picard comes off as more bloodless in his rationale. At one point, he angrily tells Geordi that the Borg is a thing, not a person.
I have a DVD set somewhere (probably in storage) that collected all the Borg episodes in various Trek series. The TNG stuff was interesting since it was so character driven by Picard and how his views of the Borg changed over time.
Wiggle, wiggle, wiggle like a bowl of soup
Wiggle, wiggle, wiggle like a rolling hoop
Wiggle, wiggle, wiggle like a ton of lead
Wiggle - you can raise the dead
Pex Lives!
Wiggle, wiggle, wiggle like a rolling hoop
Wiggle, wiggle, wiggle like a ton of lead
Wiggle - you can raise the dead
Pex Lives!
- Dr. Medulla
- Atheistic Epileptic
- Posts: 116571
- Joined: 15 Jun 2008, 2:00pm
- Location: Straight Banana, Idaho
Re: Star Trek
Granted. He does draw from his experience, but the degree that trauma informs his view is pretty open to interpretation. I wonder, tho, if the trauma angle better explains him backing away from the plan, of appreciating that he would be victimizing Hugh in the same way he was. Perhaps.Flex wrote: ↑08 Aug 2018, 5:03pmI think you're right to critique Picard and Riker this way overall, but Picard is also dealing with it from a place of trauma - I recall the episode makes pretty clear how colored he is in his perceptions from his experience as Locutus.Dr. Medulla wrote: ↑08 Aug 2018, 4:41pmAs I recall, he came up with the idea fairly early into the episode, but fencing with Guinan confirmed the wisdom of his plan after Crusher introduced some doubt. But where Guinan is motivate by revenge, Picard comes off as more bloodless in his rationale. At one point, he angrily tells Geordi that the Borg is a thing, not a person.
It's kinda a testament to Voyager's overall limp quality that it made the Borg painfully dull. The only episode that comes to mind that was interesting was when they found some Borg device and it caused 36 of D to experience the personalities of people who had been assimilated.I have a DVD set somewhere (probably in storage) that collected all the Borg episodes in various Trek series. The TNG stuff was interesting since it was so character driven by Picard and how his views of the Borg changed over time.
"Grab some wood, bub.'" - Richard Nixon, Checkers Speech, abandoned early draft
Re: Star Trek
I haven't seen this ep in ages—why were they not a threat at that time? Were they in hiding or something?Dr. Medulla wrote: ↑08 Aug 2018, 4:13pmMaybe. A genuine existential threat would justify that extreme action, but the Borg at that point weren't that threat. And, again, Picard goes straight to genocide—no reflection, no soul searching.BostonBeaneater wrote: ↑08 Aug 2018, 4:10pmI have to disagree. Threats like the Borg or like Trump need a swift clock in the jaw and a swift neutering.Dr. Medulla wrote: ↑08 Aug 2018, 3:45pmIt's that kind of rationalization, tho, that facillitates a genocidal solution. Denying any connection, any shared quality between you and your enemy makes it easier to assert a different set of rules between you and them, including those that say genocide is wrong. Given that Starfleet is supposed to represent the greatest of humanity's values and this search to meet other peoples, Picard and Riker way too quickly and remorselessly go to genocide. It's that almost eagerness that is so offputting.Kory wrote: ↑08 Aug 2018, 3:10pmAren't the Borg kind of like a humanoid space virus though?Dr. Medulla wrote: ↑07 Aug 2018, 3:22pm"I, Borg" is on right now. Christ but Picard and Riker are quick to endorse genocide. As in bloodless logic, no regrets (rather Borglike in that respect). Crusher is the only one with a conscience. Even Picard's change of heart comes from Hugh expressing an individualist perspective, so wiping out collective societies is seemingly still on the table. By all rights, Picard's and Riker's standing with at least some fans should be seriously compromised.
"Suck our Earth dick, Martians!" —Doc
- Dr. Medulla
- Atheistic Epileptic
- Posts: 116571
- Joined: 15 Jun 2008, 2:00pm
- Location: Straight Banana, Idaho
Re: Star Trek
I don't think they'd been seen since Best of Both Worlds. They're a threat, yes, but an “omigosh if we don't act now and in this radical way” threat? No way. In the TNG sphere, BoBW pretty much ends the Borg's immediate threat, and the next couple encounters don't make them out to be that dire. Picard and Riker go into a crisis mode like Americans who thought the US needed to nuke Moscow asap.
"Grab some wood, bub.'" - Richard Nixon, Checkers Speech, abandoned early draft
- Flex
- Mechano-Man of the Future
- Posts: 35943
- Joined: 15 Jun 2008, 2:50pm
- Location: The Information Superhighway!
Re: Star Trek
I'd rather be a Borg than a Democrat!Dr. Medulla wrote: ↑08 Aug 2018, 6:01pmI don't think they'd been seen since Best of Both Worlds. They're a threat, yes, but an “omigosh if we don't act now and in this radical way” threat? No way. In the TNG sphere, BoBW pretty much ends the Borg's immediate threat, and the next couple encounters don't make them out to be that dire. Picard and Riker go into a crisis mode like Americans who thought the US needed to nuke Moscow asap.
Wiggle, wiggle, wiggle like a bowl of soup
Wiggle, wiggle, wiggle like a rolling hoop
Wiggle, wiggle, wiggle like a ton of lead
Wiggle - you can raise the dead
Pex Lives!
Wiggle, wiggle, wiggle like a rolling hoop
Wiggle, wiggle, wiggle like a ton of lead
Wiggle - you can raise the dead
Pex Lives!